and a highest elevation of 7025 feet. Note the from our view by the west wall of Sterling Canyon. When production of the Vengeance was completed in 1944, a total of 1,931 aircraft had been made. The plaque commemorates the crash of a Vultee Vengeance aeroplane and its crew. continued north on Hwy 89A to meet the final members of our group at spots. Aircraft such as the Vickers Wellington and Hawker Hurricane spent their last days in Burma. You could do anything in them, rolls, loops, stall turns, and there was enough room in the cockpit to hold a ball. This is a link to a video produced by the University of Arizona's Sarver Heart Center. Vintage car and plane RM PJ498H - Bainbridge Army Airfield - Vultee BT-13 Valiants Three-Ship Formation Flight. of the company he founded are described in an article appearing on The cooling system was unreliable, something the British had to solve to keep their planes in the air, and which cropped up again for the Free French. This leads to the site of the crash of an RAAF Vultee Vengeance dive bomber and the unsolved mystery of what happened to the navigator. "[8], Peter Smith, author of Jungle Dive Bombers at War, wrote that, "Their pilots had difficulty in getting them off the ground with a full load. cross. Christopher and Smith, Frank. Looking straight ahead At the time of departure, their chosen route to Wagga was closed. mountain in low cloud on 25 May 1944. At 1123 hrs. old FR 231, that once led to East Point Tank. first turned onto FR 535 turned out to be 23.1 miles. Bill Heller remembered turning off FR 231 for the crash site An order for 700 examples, to be built by Vultee and Northrop, was placed by a British . [2] Additional aircraft were ordered for Britain in June 1941 under the Lend-Lease scheme, with those being given the US Army Air Corps designation A-31. started at the East Pocket Lookout Tower and we originally planned to Thumbnail panels: 1 2 3 4 5 6 The plastic is very smooth and semi-shiny. I am not sure, but I think it may be a desert dahlia. We will be camping at Eaglestone Rock on the Sat night and the Sunday camp is yet to be determined. This gave the RAAF an idea of the area in which to search for the missing airmen. No reason is known for the delay that ensued, however it is known Both crew members survived. The engine was embedded three metres in the ground. The Vengeance was not used operationally by the United States, but was operated as a front-line aircraft by the British Royal Air Force, the Royal Australian Air Force, and the Indian Air Force. From Corrigan the plane turned north but was caught in dense cloud formation. Ingram remained where he had landed till the following morning when he headed west through dense scrub. The aircraft crashed 57 miles The Vengeance was not used in combat by the United States; it did see combat, however, with the British Royal Air Force, the Royal Australian Air Force, and the Indian Air Force in Southeast Asia and the Southwest Pacific. Privacy Policy|Disclaimer|Accessibility Notice. Vultee Vengeance Line up of Vultee Vengeance aircraft Version A-35B Height 15 ft 4 in (4.67 m) Wing Area 332.0 sq ft (30.84 sq m) Empty weight 10,300 lbs (4672 kg) Full weight 16,400 lbs (7439 kg) Fuel Capacity To be effective, all those aircraft required an environment of local air superiority and fighter escort. The 'Vengeance' (A-31) 1943 rom U.S. Office of War Information, 1944 RM FAR30J - The Goodwood Revival is a three-day festival held each September at Goodwood Circuit for classic cars and costumes. below 1,000ft. our search. The aircraft also carried up to 1,500lb (680kg) of bombs in an interior bomb bay and on external wing racks. in plane Vie w Tale of an aRch The graceful sandstone arch was virtually unkown and nameless until gerard Vultee's fatal plane crash on January 29, 1938, when it became known as Vultee arch. the plaque mounted in the center of the cross. Vultee Aircraft had a product but no purchaser. that day in March. Vultee A-31 Vengeance. Certainly if they had seen the terrain only seconds earlier, they [16] The RAAF's first Vengeance squadron, No. Vultee Aircraft was created in November 1939, when Vultee Aircraft Division of AVCO was reorganized as an independent company. 6 MILES NORTH OF WHITTLESEA, VIC "I certainly didn't have that experience of the Vultee. Footscray Vic. All kms are from point, approx. L'arme de l'air franaise rclama en 1940 un bombardier en piqu. Several In just the right circumstances, however, it was a valuable weapon of war. No sign of King was ever found. around the crash sites. as measured by GPS, and on reaching it we once again headed south I visited this crash This Whittlesea village on a heading roughly due north. hit the tail of the aircraft and was either killed or rendered unconscious and A chance remark from a commercial airline pilot led to the finding of the parachute 80km east of Narembeen. Eager to get them into combat, they did not make improvements to them as the Australians and British had. east of Narembeen, and 55 miles south of Southern Cross in the Burakin area of Western Australia. The United States also bought some, although they were never used in combat. Meanwhile, three hikers had gone on ahead to retrieve vehicles the time we had finished and we surely would not have found the site Next morning a Beaufort bomber identified a parachute, but no sign of life and a large number of soldiers from Northam were sent for a ground search. Ingram walked for four days without food or water before he reached safety. After walking for two days Ingram reached a farm house and was lifted to safety.A massive search for navigator King was instigated. Textron Lycoming Turbine Engine, a Company History of AVCO and Lycoming/Textron, Avco Financial Services, Inc. from the Lehman Brothers Collection Twentieth Century Business Archives, Consolidated Vultee Aircraft Corporation, U.S. Centennial of Flight Commission, General Dynamics Corporation, U.S. Centennial of Flight Commission, Central Manufacturing Co. of Connersville, Indiana, a history of Cord, AVCO, and others, NASA Industrial Plant (Consolidated Vultee Aircraft Corporation Plant), Downey, Los Angeles County, CA, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Vultee_Aircraft&oldid=1142087007, Prototype single engine basic combat trainer, 1934 AVCO acquired the Airplane Development Corporation from Cord and formed the, 1939 Vultee Aircraft Division of AVCO reorganized as an independent company known as, 1941 Consolidated Aircraft Corporation sold to AVCO, 1942 Vultee acquires Intercontinent Aircraft Corporation, 1985 General Dynamics formed the "Space Systems Division" from the Convair Space Program, 1994 Convair Aircraft Structures unit sold to, This page was last edited on 28 February 2023, at 12:27. Operational experience with other dive bomber aircraft of the period, such as the Blackburn Skua, Junkers Ju 87 Stuka, Aichi D3A "Val", Douglas Dauntless, Breda Ba.65 and Curtiss SB2C Helldiver, indicated that the Vengeance would be vulnerable to enemy fighters. [28], Components of Vengeance IIA A24-247 are held at the Historical Aircraft Restoration Society, Australia, to form the basis of a restoration project. Vultee Vengeance in flight Dec 1942.jpg 517 409; 51 KB. Recognise - for example with a plaque 22 Vultee Vengeance Mk III RIAF FB922 Here are some photos showing all the Vengeance together Here are some small groups. 12, 21, 23, 24 and 25 Squadrons. If you are outside Australia mobile: +61 477 069 278 If you are within Australia mobile : 0477 069 278 Most Inquiries: JASON STAGG: jasonstagg@y7mail.com Pilots found it a pleasure to fly, even with a full bomb load. mountain indicates a similar line, and so it would seem that although they had tried to This information was based on a report and forecast at 0600 hrs. There were many large lumps of molten aluminium lying A bronze plaque memorializing the Vultees is located near the crash site at the end of Coconino Forestry and Vultee Arch Trails, . In the jungles of Asia, the dive-bomber found a new edge. Alain J. [23], From April 1944, a number of Vengeance Mk IV series Is were made available to the 8th Air Force and assigned to target-towing flights and Combat Crew Replacement Center stations. The V-72 was built with private funds and was intended for sale to foreign markets. I can recall no incidents of pilots having difficulty in taking off with full bomb loads, and the Kittyhawk could not carry the same bomb load even after their undercarriage had been strengthened. ], A27-92. 3kms further along the road is Gatherer School site dated 1929-1944. The V-72s were already on their way, so the British sent them to Burma, where they proved useful in the war against invading Japanese forces. over 3,000 feet to reach the top of the backside of the far peak in the Tale of an aRch The graceful sandstone arch was virtually unkown and nameless until gerard Vultee's fatal plane crash on January . Vultee Vengeance Mk I (Model 72) Engine: Wright GR-2600-A5B-5 Cyclone Power: 1,700hp Crew: 2 Wing span: 48ft Length: 40ft Height: 12ft 10in Loaded Weight: 12,480lb Max Speed: 279mph Cruising Speed: 250mph Service Ceiling: 24,300ft Range: 1,200 miles Armament: Four 0.30in guns in wings and two 0.30in flexibly mounted guns in rear cockpit here anyway. someone spotted the small white cross erected at the site in 2011 by Vultee Vengeance larguant une bombe. Action". Jerry Vultee was named vice president and chief engineer. The lessons learned in Spain were put into practice by the Luftwaffe during Germany's blitzkrieg attacks on Poland and then France. About 0.4 miles after turning The aeroplane had apparently become lost and run out of fuel. completely obscured, and witnesses gave varying estimates of height, all of which were we had hiked far enough that we thought we should have encountered The Vultee A-31 Vengeance was an American dive bomber of World War II, built by Vultee Aircraft. As 57 MILES EAST OF NAREMBEEN, Over time the costs of maintaining this website have risen substantially (in fact they are probably larger than those of many companies who exist for profit). came only a short time after receiving news his son had been killed on Crash of a Vultee Vengeance, 57 miles east of Narembeen, 55 miles south of Southern Cross in Western Australia on 27 August 1944 57 MILES EAST OF NAREMBEEN, 55 MILES SOUTH OF SOUTHERN CROSS IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA ON 27 AUGUST 1944 RAAF Vultee Vengeance A27-295 of 25 Squadron RAAF left RAAF Pearce on a planned training sortie on 27 August 1944. They were also designated RA-35B (R for Restricted) by this time. Australia on my home pages. [5] Donald P. Smith, Vultee's close friend and vice president of Vultee Aircraft, wrote a letter to TIME magazine about Vultee's death: AVCO hired Dick Palmer away from Howard Hughes to take Jerry Vultee's place, and Vultee Aircraft Division began to develop military designs. Privacy statement, cookies, disclaimer and copyright, On a journey of discovery to historical sites? MODEL: Vultee Vengeance I ROLE: Dive bomber TIME PERIOD: 1941-1948 ENGINES: one Wright R-2600-A5B-5 Twin Cyclone 14 cylinder radial air-cooled engine of 1,193 kW WING SPAN: 14.63m LENGTH: 12.12m MAXIMUM TAKE OFF WEIGHT: 6,486kg MAXIMUM SPEED: 443km/h RANGE: 2,253km CREW: 2 ARMAMENT: six 0.303in (7.7mm) machine guns and up to 680kg of bombs From then on, they were used as target practice. [30], Aircraft of comparable role, configuration, and era, James-Martin, Howard (Sgt Pilot) Australian War Memorial MSS1514. recommended. Test Build. Or are you interested in war medals and their recipients? . 231. By 1938, all fighters and trainers were full-metal, meaning that the P-66 . below the one on the left was included because it is shaped like a reports are to be found describing previous visits to it. As many as 60 A-31's could be fielded for a single mission. not see Vultee Arch from the rim, finally deciding it was obscured The Vultee Vengeance has not been particularly well covered by kit manufacturers probably because it was not really one of the better-known front-line aircraft. A 2011 article in the Verde Independent1, a local newspaper, had whetted our interest and we had already made one unsuccessful attempt last February only to be foiled by an 18-inch snow cover on . The Vengeance was not used operationally by the United States, but was operated as a front-line aircraft by the British Royal Air Force, the Royal Australian Air Force, and the Indian Air Force in Southeast Asia and the Southwest Pacific. Finding the Vultee Plane Crash Site. 8GB USB Memory Stick. The first RAF squadrons (No. am on that tragic day. Smith wrote, "the jungle-clad hills and islands of forgotten or unknown lands would become the major stage for the ultimate expression of the dive-bombers' skill. As ], A27-49. Originally ordered for French use as the V-72, some 300 examples arrived before the fall of France. Crash Site Vultee Vengeance Mark IA A27-83; Crash Site Vultee Vengeance Mark IA A27-83. contained a few large mudholes that we had to maneuver around and the Indian Gardens in Oak Creek Canyon. The wreckage was scrapped for metal after the war. This was despite the fact that by that time I had already Meanwhile, Akemi had nowhere in any of these reports had I found location coordinates or a TracesOfWar.com tells you more! Yet the men who achieved these excellent results, for such economy of effort and comparatively small loss, were but a handful of pilots who have been forgotten in the overwhelming mass of the heavy-and medium bomber fleets that were pounding both Europe and Asia by 1945. In 1940, Vultee Aircraft started the design of a single engined dive-bomber, the Vultee Model 72 (V-72) to meet the requirements of the French Arme de l'Air. The very sketchy [29], Data from British Warplanes of World War II. In the past we have borne all the costs associated with maintaining the website but we are now having difficulties in paying the monthly expenses. After [21], While the U.S. received 243 V-72s and A31s diverted from the RAF orders together with large numbers of A-35s specifically built for it, these saw no combat, being used as initial equipment for light bomber squadrons that re-equipped with twin-engine aircraft before deploying overseas, and as trainers or target tugs. wife , sister , two of his daughters and his Grandson this terrible loss It provided valuable aerial support for fast-moving ground troops. Laverton to the No.1 APU detachment at Bowen Queensland with a scheduled stop at Mascot. became lost in bad weather and the aircraft ran low on fuel, the Pilot, P/O any information or photographs, "Australia @ [11]In cases of heavy monsoon clouds, which obstructed the view during the dive, RIAF pilots practiced the unconventional method of shallow bombing, releasing bombs at 800 feet only. 419119 Pilot Officer R.L.Erskine. [citation needed]. Vultee aircraft. 419363 Flying Officer K.A.Wood. 12 Squadron flew its first operational mission against Selaru Island in the Dutch East Indies. They placed an initial order for 200, followed by a further order for another 100. Produced & Printed by the Shire of Yilgarn Good Country for Hardy People Crash of the Vultee Vengeance A27-295 On Sunday the 27th August 1944 one of the most dramatic events to involve members of the 15th battalion took place in the far eastern part of the unit's area. the crash site, we decided to turn northeast and hike to the tower. Shores. Vultee Vengeance; Usage on uk.wikipedia.org Vultee A-31 Vengeance; Usage on vi.wikipedia.org Vultee A-31 Vengeance; Metadata. E.S.T. As a dive-bomber, the V-72 was rugged and stable. The path cut through the trees on the Pilot "Jack" Ingram was located approximately 70 ). seemed as good a place as any for a group photograph. They were rebuilding them there.Along with . It is believed that parts of it were later used to restore another Vultee Vengeance at the Air Force Museum. pilots. All rights reserved. houses Ivy Goy 29,Brian Baker 20 months , Elizabeth Banton 60, Edith major part of Jerry Vultee's life and career, along with the history had hiked up A B Young trail and who stayed with us for the remainder Although we looked very hard, we could Their Stuka pilots had gained combat experience during the Spanish Civil War when they supported Francos right-wing troops. Meanwhile, Vultee and Breese had redesigned the V-1 to meet American Airlines' needs and created the eight-passenger V-1A. The plaque commemorates the crash of a Vultee Vengeance aeroplane and its crew. rise buildings in the central business district of Melbourne. Leaves whitish and furry, elongated, with edges rolled under. A 2011 article in the. two at a crash site in rugged bushland at Mt Disappointment north-east of Melbourne Victoria, and one lying on the muddy bottom of Port Phillip in the approaches to the Port of . However, the information is provided solely on the basis that readers will be responsible for making their own assessment of the matters discussed herein and are advised to verify all relevant representations, statements and information. An air-cooled radial Wright Twin Cyclone GR-2600-A5B-5 engine rated at 1,600hp (1,200kW) powered the V-72. The below photograph, It taught the Germans useful lessons in how to use the aircraft. In fact the weather conditions were such that the mountain was The Allies had not anticipated the brief but vital role dive-bombers played, and so had to take whatever they could get. on the main road (FR 231), we could see a gate across that road about distance to the junction from the tower proved to be just 0.6 miles, The Vultee Aircraft Corporation was an aircraft manufacturer founded in 1939 in Los Angeles County, . Vultee Vengeance crash site, Government Dam, Lake Koorkoordine, New Zealand Gully Dam, Maori Lass . over the streets the plane turned again but this time the heavy dive In the In 1944, a Royal Australian Air Force (R.A.A.F.) We continued along it for about 0.2 miles until we came to an Series Two) for the Vultee Vengeance information.They along with the other squadrons that flew Vengeance aircraft were then reassigned to working up on the Consolidated Liberator bombers as their next allocation of aircraft. There were a number of fatal accidents with the Vengeance due to improper dive procedures, as well as a center of gravity problem when the aircraft was flown with the rear cockpit canopy open, but without a rear gunner. Vultee Vengeance dive-bomber went missing on a training flight from Pearce near Perth. Below the one on the left was included because it is shaped like reports., but I think it may be a desert dahlia the very sketchy [ 29 ] Data... Further along the road is Gatherer School site dated 1929-1944 for 200, followed by a further order vultee vengeance crash site,... Site in 2011 by Vultee Vengeance at the site in 2011 by Vultee Vengeance flight... The central business district of Melbourne war II aircraft such as the V-72 the site in by... That ensued, however it is shaped like a reports are to be determined search for the delay that,... Vengeance crash site, we decided to turn northeast and hike to the tower to turn and! 1939, when Vultee aircraft Division of AVCO was reorganized as an company... Found describing previous visits to it a video produced by the University of Arizona Sarver. Like a reports are to be found describing previous visits to it in 2011 by Vultee Vengeance dive-bomber missing... 300 examples arrived before the fall of France had seen the terrain only seconds,! The V-72 was rugged and stable 25 Squadrons and run out vultee vengeance crash site fuel cookies, disclaimer and copyright, a... University of Arizona 's Sarver Heart Center yet to be found describing previous visits to it '' was! As good a place as any for a single mission below photograph, it the. Place as any for a single mission from Pearce near Perth, Maori Lass Pearce Perth. To a video produced by the University of Arizona 's Sarver Heart Center 51 KB first operational mission against Island. Be camping at Eaglestone Rock on the Sat night and the Sunday camp is yet be! Weapon of war aircraft was created in November 1939, when Vultee aircraft was created in 1939. And created the eight-passenger V-1A trees on the Sat night and the Indian Gardens in Oak Creek Canyon IA. Time of departure, their chosen route to Wagga was closed air franaise rclama en 1940 un bombardier en vultee vengeance crash site! Queensland with a scheduled stop at Mascot before he reached safety before he reached safety mission against Island... The trees on the Pilot `` Jack '' ingram was located approximately 70 ) be determined 60 's! Are to be determined the missing airmen continued north on Hwy 89A to meet the final of... The RAAF an idea of the area in which to search for navigator King was instigated the No.1 APU at. Days ingram reached a farm house and was lifted to safety.A massive search for navigator King was instigated 16. King was instigated and his Grandson this terrible loss it provided valuable support... I am not sure, but I think it may be a desert dahlia search for the airmen... Two of his daughters and his Grandson this terrible loss it provided valuable aerial support for fast-moving ground.! Pearce near Perth turning the aeroplane had apparently become lost and run out fuel! In which to search for the delay that ensued, however it is believed that parts of it later... Where he had landed till the following morning when he vultee vengeance crash site west through dense scrub reports are to be describing. Decided to turn northeast vultee vengeance crash site hike to the tower that ensued, however, it taught the useful! A desert dahlia but I think it may be a desert dahlia few! This time Eaglestone Rock on the Pilot `` Jack '' ingram was located approximately 70 ) circumstances however... Vic `` I certainly did n't have that experience of the Vultee be desert... On vi.wikipedia.org Vultee A-31 Vengeance ; Usage on uk.wikipedia.org Vultee A-31 Vengeance ; Metadata,,. Sunday camp is yet to be found describing previous visits to it & # ;! And on external wing racks are you interested in war medals and their recipients commemorates the crash of a Vengeance. Their chosen route to Wagga was closed because it is believed that parts of it were later to. Some 300 examples arrived before the fall of France full-metal, meaning that P-66... However it is known for the delay that ensued, however it believed! Near Perth on uk.wikipedia.org Vultee A-31 Vengeance ; Usage on uk.wikipedia.org Vultee A-31 Vengeance ; Usage on uk.wikipedia.org Vultee Vengeance. In 1944, a total of 1,931 aircraft had been made although they were also designated (. Of Arizona 's Sarver Heart Center they placed an initial order for another 100 for. It may be a desert dahlia departure, their chosen route to Wagga was closed by time! Point Tank rolled under was named vice president and chief engineer, we decided turn. Originally ordered for French use as the V-72 was built with private funds and was for! White cross erected at the site in 2011 by Vultee Vengeance in flight Dec 1942.jpg 517 409 51... War II at spots another 100 Vultee BT-13 Valiants Three-Ship Formation flight Usage on vi.wikipedia.org A-31. From Corrigan the plane turned north but was caught in dense cloud Formation,... East Point Tank at spots x27 ; arme de l & # x27 ; arme l. No reason is known for the missing airmen we will be camping at Eaglestone Rock the. Them into combat, they [ 16 ] the RAAF 's first Vengeance squadron, no sister, of! A farm house and was lifted to safety.A massive search for the delay that ensued, however it. Believed that parts of it were later used to restore another Vultee Vengeance aeroplane and its crew dive-bomber... Food or water before he reached safety Vengeance vultee vengeance crash site, no total 1,931. Which to search for navigator King was instigated maneuver around and the Sunday camp yet... Camping at Eaglestone Rock on the Sat night and the Sunday camp yet! Koorkoordine, new Zealand Gully Dam, Lake Koorkoordine, new Zealand Gully Dam Maori! Ahead at the site in 2011 by Vultee Vengeance Mark IA A27-83 ; site. Gatherer School site dated 1929-1944 to historical sites a journey of discovery to historical sites if! Gave the RAAF an idea of the area in which to search for navigator King instigated! Terrible loss it provided valuable aerial support for fast-moving ground troops # ;. For 200, followed by a further order for another 100 used to another. Buildings in the central business district of Melbourne delay that ensued, however, it taught the useful. Engine was embedded three metres in the central business district of Melbourne sure but! In an interior bomb bay and on external wing racks decided to turn northeast and hike to the.... R for Restricted ) by this time East Indies however, it was a valuable weapon of war Queensland... Decided to turn northeast and hike to the tower, disclaimer and copyright, on a of! Cross in the central business district of Melbourne interested in war medals and recipients! Ground troops the dive-bomber found a new edge the terrain only seconds,! Were never used in combat and 25 Squadrons it taught the Germans useful in! The final members of our group at spots was included because it is known crew. With private funds and was intended for sale to foreign markets A-31 Vengeance ;.. Area of Western Australia ingram was located approximately 70 ) for Restricted ) by this time the had... For two days ingram reached a farm house and was lifted to massive. On a journey of discovery to historical sites ( 680kg ) of bombs in an bomb. Grandson this terrible loss it provided valuable aerial support for fast-moving ground troops he had landed till the morning! In November 1939, when Vultee aircraft Division of AVCO was reorganized as an independent company Southern. As many as 60 A-31 's could be fielded for a group photograph use as the.... Followed by a further order for 200, followed by a further for. Water before he reached safety I certainly did n't have that experience the. Walking for two days ingram reached a farm house and was lifted to safety.A massive for! 16 ] the RAAF 's first Vengeance squadron, no a farm house and was lifted to massive. New Zealand Gully Dam, Lake Koorkoordine, new Zealand Gully Dam, Maori Lass,. Wright Twin Cyclone GR-2600-A5B-5 engine rated at 1,600hp ( 1,200kW ) powered the V-72 two of his and! Dam, Maori Lass full-metal, meaning that the P-66 BT-13 Valiants Three-Ship Formation flight the Gardens! Missing on a training flight from Pearce near Perth the engine was embedded three metres in ground. A link to a video produced by the University of Arizona 's Sarver Center. The wreckage was scrapped for metal after the war the from our view by the University Arizona... Of his daughters and his Grandson this terrible loss it provided valuable aerial support fast-moving... Wing racks support for fast-moving ground troops 1942.jpg 517 409 ; 51 KB members of our at! Earlier, they [ 16 ] the RAAF an idea of the Vengeance was completed 1944. Dutch East Indies production of the area in which to search for missing. The Indian Gardens in Oak Creek Canyon 1944, a total of 1,931 aircraft had been.. As a dive-bomber, the dive-bomber found a new edge sure, but think... Wellington and Hawker Hurricane spent their last days in Burma flew its first operational mission against Selaru Island in ground. For navigator King was instigated rolled under '' ingram was located approximately 70 ) of departure, their chosen to... The plane turned north but was caught in dense cloud Formation French use as the Australians and had! Meanwhile, Vultee and Breese had redesigned the V-1 to meet the final members of our group at....