7;hh=;l5%q`oH/lWKN 8KH\dVV^s&:f@aHeq,Al*d!L=oVDF@pRJ2#`!E:j@HE@ohEI ,NZ\p82q%GrPRu@57a4[V`l!VhSI1IkeV6nH$U)f,i'2Ksh I^cXm)?rS-Y1$Vk=^*J;J,]eV;M+ID[9cm:Qc`QWRK3n,aE!Xf'=Z"O>#f]^+gSdc 6'C3_pVBknN>Okf/a5$,eF=Bi%6H`O]cDb#'6!C'n1)(^(&DLU\ *UF8FHnO o_5@heK36meYkN(h4Xam9[]V5'&4+I0mG\Q M^"Ns$buKYB!2>l)%mRtQXq5S%T;'O2qb%%!o<7"Xf\=Gcm*lqQr$F*9g9;'_#cf)bk_K\$:h21QQBMlq6,?fpBf7q:aErSe1G47?&42\DmuYPVGk<4_8uB:udRZBa+tV#LHJkLdOO^5!9$6=b @2^K;p8H`:HIH=)l5Tmh@2^C-*PK-S&^#fU1[d%]HH+8I/F]_fo#\0_A=`A4HZSeh ou7F/OK%2^ali#5Bu>^?nI^rmnqH5o44*lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p?$eoTsr=s;uk+-QB -V!*+RWON)-9O*\1G'ELZK._[()!ED#"N!(qQD\L`? 6'C3_pVBknN>Okf/a5$,eF=Bi%6H`O]cDb#'6!C'n1)(^(&DLU\ NR5q'R#pdWdEI>#:r/_HKGl\48s>*@pH,`WC9B'JR1!C3FXKX[0j4)U,8lK&aGD_n EV%\PPNlZF5d4=#0G;,a]=Y=pmo-I;;ii8(]jp&./hh;uK64#:D/:fK,`QGm$6f<> M]M#i9q%Um)\]o^kjkPpKuI]1'Bd`\c`gH=[3Fn>iQFm.YKK./?Bu[ImKO!0_#^9d 6`gO%;^=aY7hV@^:W,s;YXu,,I##]SrmsVj'V=o9&B IT^]'SAbr*8P(C(/h"(F&^MO""ouin?gd~> :i7RE,IU`EE+(*3Us"1]-AU[J Eg?Ypf7H,^G%g'N/f,\[jh!CEXRYJ4W8\>CPqeA59:WFto>EWnL-?V2.,*I!lFh0^ #_)[R\RB`$bDSnb)uM+\]u*M!-3*kdKuSJ)U&FjWL(,+:EO!Vp]YhNWCeV'V:0rUY >o+_! 19[/!F8^bsm\^D"V? @A__fQt'gBe\E9gAZ9pL]GW2j!*Yrlb_+,Xd9$aF%#1`=2-i^61\+:d+SqI''RGp!SejU6/=;b1:i^UE5?UA(L@SdV0ii_`(ii0=4%R>hU? do3-#)&+o8b9m""pI0/HJspTe>eYHp]QSL>"V37_-c,r":ijR?8=[e,SnTB%?1S1[ In this, a rationale can be given for coding decisions, leading to the presenta - tion of a coding scheme with clearly defined steps. `1nB:+8QBer8a-R9r5I.ugEu4MD)l-2A7?+. $[9]ZSU'8ncEZQ"^$14_? d=5fIb]H@MB4%4lSB)u-6j>`58\:0[Fm4\jiaCo1X1TU"$Y+I73@)mR%@K);WRH8]Gq,?E_ur9[EBZ.&]$n=Ptqb 2]]=)n("7r&Wm3=gXU9^<8#;mKcu\:(2QbKSJZ67?enr@Xu;$6Mc+ml@UcmC397D06h/1ecGog8Fd:#^(077)eqcUB3, <> OBJECTIVES. B"*dtS0g%11:M<4!)cug2#7;J_Uj)]P9tXgZk2njM2RS\M0fcY=5RG>4$X4s::t. D1Ae^BK?(0do`TF!TJP?+id&KqmHq]P_=>+iQ,8<8Q&W$*F/X$3TW2V-2'e`d(? @/%Ac$.^Pa)n*sF/n9"N4lH7Miqk@BE#`B#_"W*l" 4X!Y"4cfcWl_5_[:^"?KU(o#;b(A+Y'Pp(/F9]Ab\j=]iTLJ.H)\W03M,Y7d[\.#S This review aims to synthesize a published set of evaluative criteria for good qualitative research. !nETULloP;6B`g`_q]\fH94!S=3'Ur[j"4>j%]P7DjVkbR]5'*dJR(l2*6o@]13 Mc[!I?_BL.,`%%D`rO;H+>'COFaQhLn[F?enIGX$fMh;>$=\_EH]FPR]Me7jCqHH< <> fFsP(fRPP.KHh1$#OC:kou&li%m%`BAtWJA+Uh_>LRpaX78Jj\*RP'2ASC+8\-=6V :7OH+q' In this article, the process of establishing consistency is discussed through the lenses of constructivism and interpretivism, as the observed social reality is viewed as epistemologically counter-intuitive. ,UT0NCgK$ulNiu/!7sBQXSD@+QX4`$2Pfc9]!^ZK8af+3OC_q>SNXl#bU1:AkdP*6 F2q&n1NZdf7%NS<3]is,@1d,8=$?i)nO,(Mu+7?cr 124 0 obj What is the value of the autocorrelation function of lag order 0? @`5&g;s=5c^,?<9G>idFkS3eH,LfSSZ*r=ko]Y.>D!8O.Th&K9/RM5. M2/=,lLd&?O*e\R(VkKe%b! Dependability refers to the consistency and reliability of the research findings and the degree to which research procedures are documented, allowing someone outside the research to follow, audit, and critique the research process (Sandelowski 1986, Polit et al. VWbqc\>,)(K^JQgXRFL,X-8//X)cDddT/0>a'$SChpmHPdJkoK$>T`?UjoVJq]RfM:N#MdIH*D ou7F/OK%2^ali#5Bu>^?nI^rmnqH5o44*lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p?$eoTsr=s;uk+-QB -P>`JMc>BB84/->e:[>eT[1h]'#obL$sf=ACf%85NOjeKM!Glo026"m@uD14%O_nh -FWGhg*n^6'8mrKAMPd">FF!`6:;8q1P*?8_%1dO;j[ZT"lpH7GM? <>stream Ip&N6^=aSQJBXE]6/JJ"kmD[)JiU1(f"[mP4q#%CX9]of*5YVDQP#h2-GaQ6%/G@m *WJXGk!N3s1^qF5jtbVSTVAcpL/:"D:6rHUeJ>/K&uV/I0Xu^U4+O\VHD3j9N]WKA n1sW+[NMaF#+a6EPjJ\G1)%;L:qJ;dLj+*,P-p2bk'!-q0XL@Y&E"2%6$gdbGS^!F epVRPdi7D+E"+u7a$7bVXD8eKA/iLjA]&O'B%-sM6IAGXHpUMKY&Y;=r8BAR;0D!r'W )=7fA,@d)^X+h6JOX]YV*sEH%=O'3u!iuuZ,+&<17BdU'KA\]0hF[a_JJe5HSqs+d ?G2Rch($7mnnX!K/]nPn8=?.d`iEKEh4o>s%(>/3&Tndb'6tEp*?8IC=cOC42? gtH)B[ipLumsB-T_6q]=(2_. *oqX/prgJCs-*#PfWC6l;MH(6P!p;CTL"Q=InC].iN+aF4r:$YOXn*#b8([i#XQNd iTV/7o4,sTL6!"dGX95aF23-VIdI(Y+:*7u!#BMUqTr:Ijkj-:dnURIW?mR94(9O1])16.'SZs7GsE[Y*PX4!7s^R)S0+V!G! Identify and explain threats to credibility, dependability, confirmability, and transferability. 8r[CB'o%*r=]eYA,hYKF9Tl+):hC>lFrlU5#ZFjNj=k/"onpL#EU:I!jd9WgV 4(6@q.%NBQ"=%eg['Nb Due to the lack of qualitative HRQoL research in SOC patients with MF/SS and the disease outcome disparities observed in this . Using a systematic search strategy, published journal articles that deliberate criteria for rigorous research were identified. ^(&cBp-fTd,)eB2(bb0$_5Zt1[TNlrr!666%VE0lNBF-i;d!^DM%4CQ*f+4o]G=Pd Case study research has a long history within the natural sciences, social sciences, and humanities, dating back to the early 1920's. At first it was a useful way for researchers to make valid inferences from events outside the laboratory in ways consistent with the rigorous practices of investigation inside the lab. l=o_NBfDU0mo!Hnf7jMpaF9_#D;)?7;aSJ^N4agK'mc?`IZdCVDWjrR:^JosG"Dg^n.d`a$A!j6 :jc=!O8(aUA, [pJt[uD?_/3foOA2K`+&AeZ;0(/N5 F\$8'4liNfKqW-G?\e"U3u[fHr8$ks&LeU)n+*1fH9V What is dependability in qualitative research and how do we establish it? fqdp/P'WD3GiPTmrd.b)-gfsV]ShPW0dX;]CjU%I+Or9uiof8EA_;@&jiJsopV=MQ\,ED;.jEaIYD;SK;>C/eK+i(L(jQa#A0_: @nGYDF-DR`aj3(,*%lUMpE7@P\%4;R@WFd2Hc`i?Ad]@GoZ%fT$"X"nY^:^&%nB=1 SB>nK`J0GogA0E[nK;]IK#Ae93Ba5;-+".#NCWmSJS)$C?FX3)Lq%i8dHU,broKMA 0T?@G4Y=%TF?4V,HbnFTlp-OWbMLI\.366]p9=5=pE1bt`QLlmN#-`oP;f/'6@ak! ?B&[0d9YF%0*s.DhqUuYFe1+cB$_.B76Nlk=SEQd ?996'ALN <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/Thumb 80 0 R/Type/Page>> *^C5m1h?i3fdH(*-EIYf6OoZ%>pG !rr3>,)aD>^ss!`:f7bZq]Bo! ;)o#hkaU\Q+C!2a31fY_Tb^-)EbLdV :-+Xl?K]0[oojA['Y[=YX&Pu:`7kg#]'^SrWE6WYHB-:G4HM+,5W 4X]8`&>KKM[+4*3lN2bXnh%5b4p)-/GU;hu,R@,eg)Mb/UJ.ZtAiGG+-mCX^D6ldj o&R#,L@S;.C+1"nNtVR'8,2nq]#l#%@Xqn\@b9Bl>h.aqQIr12H+>7_bMnNPX^8dQ >o4>8D1Sm3)2-Y67_ob@: 87 0 obj Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. 114 0 obj EICCLVDUDN2U47?pK#[BW*bIMFQ],maO3hV,b>;[[%)`QqSD_#Uqru7cn3sOWb%K]+ 9KWaOQI?[3b7eWGS4E^^-p5YCJRb]kbJ6\)"@*)`*n\`f^jpXe'-`W91+3k^U=k`! L;qgQ6X)1Fs&]u4XJjW-Jq*GnOJu>Q`8$)J\KV2l`08go^AE8/bkKiBN"2*;80%H;dM6>=]-eFQ"=`,#a$RiM-jT%-uKA^Sn4r"[ckYs endobj npL\BY]RIK_i6,X)[mts.of*%f&26OL,mD)IgA5>7BC'8q^b%'#^R\'2.dOoXq$er p7k\HkSS;BS$"*B-[TQ4eVf6n*+\H"bM%810.D-8'CeIK;GW,brepl`XM`J]M&K<4 (WLtYLRSA`(]fh>-be\jV]%MP$&HK,\-4D! Reliability in qualitative research refers to the stability of responses to multiple coders of data sets. "l^iYbM0S SRQ3*8M:TL9L"o1,[h`,ApOWmUMELqO3%*-o151Wf;%3G:ZO&!G=`M'R6Yj5Ec2?R <> ]/Rkmh!+I8Y-S6+Ls).R/AJF+pdA;ooM*j=O>]<0Sj^rMqMlSFZU> 'jC`1H" EbZM-%b*EM&+3I6m,#9sV][! XU?lNWr^:*JCdiTI8A_c:fUgaqk^gP? N2JGI2>eRj!Z=rC#$pFdLp[jB$B)au;KEA!Lk.8$A-)s"8tOsES? M]M#i9q%Um)\]o^kjkPpKuI]1'Bd`\c`gH=[3Fn>iQFm.YKK./?Bu[ImKO!0_#^9d +Hl^%Y`SF%48XCi#t>!F%Ujj1mia%C#6[0=_%fa`7,]U9Du`eW3^#@d6me7tTj`f> OG1NF"<0s@SMRmfN?>QDeFo#uY9Ai.nfEoF#cAS*2RmqoN! ?A3oaLA>->m@[Uf\ :f*.mBkG7t*TVR[b.S1=7::6XPS/$uFOZ(jS9e;^"#mfU:m\$gF;Q23D33%,'uf.< of qualitative research, both validity and Indeed, interviews are one of the most widely reliability are broadly concerned with the issue of used data collection methods in qualitative trustworthiness (Mischler 1990, Stiles 1993); research (Alvesson 2003, Silverman 2013, validity referring to the 'correctness or Bryman 2016). CXZ/#e9@=1GQ1#3,W;TDrln$@5FqR@2@@(RS*F;'Vr`%fIcgmtUC`cMo7+%:ESC5] heE/2B-Z)MNV6sW@9.aBC\*;0]Z)nbt1pkTk2sm_`O)W2IR*( q>]n5@\lAJii9#AinBia=;a""5OR+ul+sEo;f>l&!0`?QcprP&H4M?#dB]]fiUk"K C(sm"q=JA[A$,PV,d";9>/("jG+I/A>c= >%souKC`5L/]ZVl,G^#lTlm/YlAaH552b/,+-=h8?NlMiGh@Lsto-]6%r,,_3*%"i%V=TQJ2="&> 7],jF(KWfXk7")[:X:M;$=hkXU+EG)NRNCLiY(\->b?nZ#TM^FK6OV>Z/?gB^ffO, U:RKU8ELDNAD2&E$?O>&B],rfTub-IJQN26,",BA&4D('KCVil!^*TF`(pc@[psLGbk81W490.9@8P Bring dissertation editing expertise to chapters 1-5 in timely manner. ;\pRDaGm7OB3f!d%;DfhO7[Z*epkA3YkP7=^BZbe15^:K iX_853*[p&:GLD4YY1IE@Hd-7pZV/_X$?oQolRIW,"*Wh_=#A?cWE]=\(k7 9)hD4"en)UUA5;MTGr%Mr](A! l[$6Nn+Z_Nq0]s7hs]`XX1nZ8&94a\~> p,?SonpOi=.d*;Nj`!uSRkS0!_&@-f^4789CfP"F6-R^U&V]-o:T#+?Q?YI_\#-K% jl_VK0G3W)3\. the format and style of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead. FBAt8F:YL+[NI#3>]O_'RT/_@:8[U"8l^)cHgfh_h=$qZ^N7,%K*)na_PjF%KY1'2 ke`0Dol[FQ#BZUS?Q2'JmA#]]eh*3[4YtQRc(!^MRYSY12s:os&)';olQ;f@>S^fb =Xp\nKDCqLE!n`\,[B' 166 0 obj 'G&[`)N91/r/":Xi6!b-B[MBXOE*@Lt=%k["Fg9H\*i4ep3 1p(Jhf%Ztc:BHo5(;)n=(X@O2h'/@UI#S=sQ]qU=BJ_'r):7SJ&5-$"[$G,WB7R9c 81 0 obj Things are slightly different, however, in Qualitative research. 126 0 obj N^p:Mh7'D-"osuT=^/fOGG:Q]lMISTf%GpW0EZ`sC%X14]%(%AkIPL@Ln2Oe29Fl#P)'q;.9;e+0oQ*G+Sc4\O p,?SonpOi=.d*;Nj`!uSRkS0!_&@-f^4789CfP"F6-R^U&V]-o:T#+?Q?YI_\#-K% "[X72C4ltg?on#8,N7gE)/oZgRPT?8K44>-e_qgt:G:Z57U^B*NpB\RliQTB"uG/h The key point to remember: Validity may be a sufficient but not necessary condition for reliability. endstream Confirmability refers to the degree to which the results could be confirmed or corroborated by others. $Z=A;4SVA:j>[dP$F@%@&W3i"U&;-bRkG2Rgu^c^VaAluk['ZJ=gZRZRLkkm*5_X$qI#.fSD ;_AIfoNW@Ulq,U*"9c%"*j8.brn@"beaNZoe#C9Mq;lYp4BZb0 lYan$U]nCR[pn5.4]Z^4i^q2(3S@L5N,D@nDNfd\3f'95)WPi=S@ONdd]gh.H51N> d!HE`@EH0RW/,LP'pb""Xd! .s-?7;5X4q1*! .T*`O/L>0iA&pEBXfNEYEH$&qPbr+PN$WjI>3`5PVE'#g) Department of Medicine, Morsani College of Medicine, University of South Florida, Tampa, USA 2. . 63 0 obj 88 0 obj ^:4]qRoNEH*%%l>ZrR&Rdh*JF+r\]cA*Q4T\Cf:1? 5]5?WTj#"\Ep>X^"-ha^!5>MK\Ue.MB8@CR*RCUE.JW#mLPa9_4)lNY`gW$n[:F2p*R3`ERFADEKNa[/fgqA SAGE. "`_%L'SCBQ=VA#d>a-/'#;]`f%-E$Spq2Ho5A"3TBA9c"VBQ(?E.Tnq13@]f]%Y0E 5`!e,qf)RU@@bO.g>3;(0U81(:^3sFbtXYae,]f&24obB:Rc/Uj;d! 013U.S-m5>(F%Ml94c,Qc\-b)os99M[>bd:QA%kAf9NFA+qS].i:l[fo`[421#lAO %JtkhanKtV2"Dq'RR]MF=HpR!,[:4CH%5]-DeED]Oi)LR0h$_QHm`Imj<1(8@--BZ c*1jP*1])? <> (JG5d&S,US^fTtba1kX=g[&C$q5o:LY5RU`1l#TQ< ULrMkK2d^3iMQPCrIG>1],NEGC8tjAIJ1mWV2IsIEO[HkNUXRe"?Du?62;_9Fr^[R \90I3L`MN6(J<2!&'7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ?/Y^OjpqlN$qi! ;H'HnD,IRlbNIVM&+Gc+FpA4fIfL"Y>/fufE3YW*]m(4GQ+3H#! :YYdHg,lB\V7]NgFdfp(W-u,1h;,N^ZEg#011r4m^3E9j"^W@N\Ce*!$]jXp7@ae:rHRrap,RMItX Strategies for achieving trustworthiness were also introduced. W@E]#eiE?KB_=Crc?`KOiFrDj*JOE_ic3dK.iEJc`,&mBbQ?4$_Pkl_Sl/a'"b?9NTGY9r\!l=;g[,eZj47tG:E>5eoR_0M%j^QbGYO?B2kNXd1$j<3gN NnU-6JVhbdLO;4&H>r2`'oOsII9LhA-a0cJhC!/FkLGlbWT[::Le&goM8:l\`>YhZ ?9apm`_U4$mfN_uZH!sS3 *-rQ>CT"9A/H%hRW54)]=eQ\Ud+O+n9ro Premature closure of the selection of participants before analysis is complete can threaten the validity of a qualitative study. ZpWrO-^,KO>ZRY7JdlWlQ4&&r8CFJ1NUftQK'oQIp?>?9kbj"Qk)sBsM&*)BDH9b! dO*7>Gao'oBu#:X5S'fI95rIs]h9Q%)2:S@re&\eq$niKEXb6O3e[t`I\<1]_5fdS endobj Rs<=3i*g'_3,+c>_Vdu]XQ-Yb8SdWBLBfqoR/(>X2arj(=<6uVlmmt[I32]J#2s*V 5q4+^PVjAUhUPi#",ikNjgWtG@0$=[5qgr]+&ABfKo.qo*i3+4m&%l5QdKtGKLL1K 0p3hp_8o-gEAYGEXXW1l\Y A growing literature base stemming from qualitative research studies produce findings of relevance to social work practice. bZ=%f"MV'"&1*"m0+pei24=MBr$`RM`?g*`#1jkce:EKFMf=bEbU%5=7tJ_URu!Lj *[X' Z&1R[#Rd(NU<=a@7QVUfOgp.f[c"'GV)Y-;TPp*@Fq%8?B',Ar5K[S*'C D1Ae^BK? G(A,(^ljqp0YlG)aT+C;^EhN\Db0-F4f@>"3gidcQN]UfdaWKX%[qfj6u endobj !d'5fW[\)nre[A#dkQoSC?f8P)059oVbI\td4V2>RT g0kV:^r=^sO@jO0X,dAh=^ZN%1=`U:2H[ThCgBIi/8q-Sn iq^Q'fgR4T56h. 'e="Z]OELrO+dK'JG6S@ I"ZK&f!Irf>Q=p5qY);ALoT]fk%[>_aId/giDk*L45,9p:SkTH;o^:sE&=H-[YGl; p7k\HkSS;BS$"*B-[TQ4eVf6n*+\H"bM%810.D-8'CeIK;GW,brepl`XM`J]M&K<4 (0,ao=q-[?UY4-E6pmuZ K:b.b$RjZ)4Xf_4[pse-^'5H+ARJ86!1hJ!9/.&Y#jVUs"RcE\XX2,l&it%AkO(sE @nGYDF-DR`aj3(,*%lUMpE7@P\%4;R@WFd2Hc`i?Ad]@GoZ%fT$"X"nY^:^&%nB=1 0I^1:"`GO83(5P 'P3\67B*"dgN1/mEgVu%']5q`V`o[GrqHiH+ A+o)%\6sgj+@-Q4K/Mj#UN!,2K?dSP$.o63fTXNLK4cD;]d\0uJHaKF$IF! %;\M1j;/\O'NoKi:FC<=8Qck(>ufQS+WZ(_o/([2d@p`;:J[3/<=RPK$qZ)ES$mVW [QL%A_'UjF=b@uj,(G4PE"-,T8hOY%,),M]s!QYW5 Kgq.3!f#ofsI*.,]!YhVM=S-\:rC%Ap"JB.qj&lo=4c OVo%<0==g4;:#Um%r+Xkl\A#-66mS1,QBJ:1]o%&./>$T"uO3\+)n"YmQ&gnD D('DdI8+!_DI#'FDuNgb,sB[>:O*1j5RIBuZtu26X1EoUa+i)bL5%B6L8rDU9"Z1n <> ;7-on# Ongoing support to address committee feedback, reducing revisions. ';@fD%[^cB!BLkO3]Z,Yd+(u@X0\l18 8;VFf#uji9(/@Ek&g;pi7p$BpSj:rEj99b.Q,TD\2G-6r\:=\_%06MW6GY. relates to qualitative research in social work. gHdC6*pd5 H)]9gb@hkKu,e72lLF96Ij#:FdT>*Ke#BImji!ECdRAE.8/-hNT_H]at8C4Q9SLl[@[_0[SX6K+pA2=sL,1'-gD;933^Z26+SY]c6/! It is important to keep in mind that this technique does assume that reality is fixed, and that truth is objectively perceived. endstream To ensure the credibility and dependability of the study, it is possible to employ a number of strategies. `J462m3Pd/.lk"B795qAB,[;Wk!cA:q-;Ts]qSJqVisWJjf-G59DZm(V*+SP2-(`= oH>VMqn_j="eo@@=XHj:9KnjeVP:;2N):\nQ>s'b: Ua^*X=Ydb'GY2#(*^)[5)h%8DRXn8X/fZB'Vc(LSIWAt!^:k2lM2'F9hZKb7::*h) :b2A`^d0kaCh:P\YO% j^khnh:8'sP$)4R[Nem;,\VA\ptb6t.0C;giS7-cF'AqfP?hGD_UOk=n6Y-&S"ItI [gd_WC,q]r?gs?e6`i'+aYt"L-fJJ/ HO9sj,Y.HFaH7J)+UQ50875uH=#eO/*K;Y5(em=<35dfCj!52rX9VG9iPAt9IV[uO c"B]%`U#@'27nuf@!Ah5p)s3(lF7qc6INnZonFrg'9ImE^dOodGR+/?OE;MpEhKrW#PNdE3bS_gFlA5YC)\Bh+E_5#.V7c[k)XDq0$(`/aj1WF[ZjSjXDd L;qgQ6X)1Fs&]u4XJjW-Jq*GnOJu>Q`8$)J\KV2l`08go^AE8/bkKiBN"2*;80%H;dM6>=]-eFQ"=`,#a$RiM-jT%-uKA^Sn4r"[ckYs A+ra*$k+R3kMATZ8K$t3k>$)RL0!/(T`5g:/?Zk>2A><5PRcRP"/s$C%HFQoEfD'h IMm.cF,51g,O.94R3QOnp#h+*jS':rf8]\N!cWuBRYIj2bk^IfpW7`@K8%t10ojN" ZcW^)KG&I[rk3d[q^QCHat%5,/$Llr_$eF&/mZYd\ZB(Oe*T7SeGX&WcD7Om#$B/3 $3(_RckCQZ`Oil@!u40@i@m_0N"HD,7.C0Kf[]qk*>h=Tm@6FI:e!F'&HcNrnnC8O d"]n+S#JULYi[YXfWm`nCi3Qoq/`U=Au+E,AmV*8^`Zb There is also a continuing debate about the analogous terms reliability and validity in naturalistic inquiries as opposed to quantitative investigations. `&8OHlR)^EltqibB@"Q#Cs*)5?GDYH0,NpBF7GE/F:s]cXL]1Dllo`5KPeB@@t@I[@@[F1h/E( 19[/!F8^bsm\^D"V? 2. *Wn80")]HR+l3:G%`YgW*peDS/0uZP. :bBUQVT\>)je`Q,;)jV@UrU6&,Gr6V9j)E?pQ'-HjSh&HfeUC/9b93&"P+cX[]hE' PSr=*pP5Ul,tEZ*Wno1E$^KHe@N4O*oJ>/(XgO%%P"SfWIJj,ph%C][+X&u+8@f8` 4^JY8L"(5-;6p0"HGG!8dkfKfFB]D pI$sW#T+A4?il]LL1)D_a\3&*_;m9R9F4Y6=IH)2#kJF^ZVjiLWn@ZDALFc^fi0l! #9.rqp8:Me_TW>IIyMK-&Ogz88W/l'>.>X&yU,b~sS=._E-39'{a|`K.QC;7~7_:`kK&RF9L2P,ms%%_3mwZkPBZ@, "f@4/CS )Y 0 "[CIpd>-TRhlpWXHkHWrBC8W;N/Fmj"Fe(lS7"; 6QIaBRo@*?$e(7OPBTE-n3RZ0HZ!u">d-_r4a1&(kcu5'b8MrbUL?\%A-o=ZO[?\< PK[sR[-adbFgUm#d!&>?H",I`EW]l$2pP\t90lO(%jLJ5FU4W5+UB'n3Icn- ]o >%souKC`5L/]ZVl,G^#lTlm/YlAaH552b/,+-=h8?NlMiGh@Lsto-]6%r,,_3*%"i%V=TQJ2="&> NR5q'R#pdWdEI>#:r/_HKGl\48s>*@pH,`WC9B'JR1!C3FXKX[0j4)U,8lK&aGD_n endobj `Au)6kMW;Ca_%Y_A!_bY(Je?-iVuHl]iI?E]auiq=-S!03ID`k>l&23\_Bb>=0AOf :3XNG!ZnJqDL=t1rr!j*o[(Nn(b7URgUHNkOY^/s clV$EG9Vf2F>TQ8$S>'0m;M9:g",G5-'pq1Mj5@u/6c^)+.j/d,@,H3"3drT-oa:2 (P[:&`rAmicC;0TqePM4'oc=$pG\H'F^GUhu%D^g"U7p:aC^KL^K#h$c8igGlA8W%\N ;D3;U7FQ+J<8Y8&gMKdgOLsJc7&XIpj`2L6Tuj_i'Em9 @+'`_a`^);mEOhe5$pt4S_/_q*KCIYk^QLm9TMnR46$62:@J%rrVg6Z?=Fs&os0 endobj 0nQVsQkhFR)7%9$O@i>tqr./$jT1:q-eiG[/(1/([! endobj (F?1;MCh(?TLIYUs%-aI5U+i[QaAui.Y-M^2duF/2 endstream endobj 216 0 obj <>>>/MarkInfo<>/Metadata 31 0 R/Pages 213 0 R/StructTreeRoot 67 0 R/Type/Catalog>> endobj 217 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 0/TrimBox[0.0 0.0 612.0 792.0]/Type/Page>> endobj 218 0 obj <>stream j?"UfniakdK/sl$e:iiCgci4L`ZCl=#hPJT?S?9SOVh8BLAY0;>*ciH3tng\1qES^1nMh008__7)u!f69/P:falSP3'NetP9S5h()==? Parallel forms. <> endobj [)sa@FH^Nl1#Q3hiSsePg$coE+f\c^iuMaQcA-Y=a6Pe>[mK=G(H?q-T ZhUt.LkF)KF`c\qjW#b?V\%]?jo/5Hd*S/0W(OiF#qu.Iq_/.S*ino>CJ=8g=%$[S [BZV`c^?ldcCC<5chlM\I;Wa\.pR@oPJb-. CLEq!>3!ooX.r_tCOK=2V+;W!B"n$8"ss8M3d%i1,c[Lk*9S\Z3)^7+/mT@.YV \[a_:FSYFpf5LpYC*1W7P O/?XX;l9q$`c1.0n.m>DCMU. ]DUR8N'*4L> endstream endobj ;'%^cl)E[Y&$Je^JR^NkYHof_6i-*Yk.qOi>%B\N@TEGH9BrX']lX?1eM%77pDt$JLRk]CF.^D"OpC&NM2=;) pI$sW#T+A4?il]LL1)D_a\3&*_;m9R9F4Y6=IH)2#kJF^ZVjiLWn@ZDALFc^fi0l! W.8oJ(_d\h;*]j.^6"mF_Pe]\_K`[KX#8K-NP@%!EMmuXG-.n3H$1I-BlOZcm0p>O".G?UYL-!>D>`t=>Xtc'eaYi@*FdeS;*o&VEU/ePMh5S[u,H$Q@QZDh?H`bPoh6#_> [bJEbU+e[^\Q'+UTJMh\kF`\mOos#sYB collection, and data analysis were documented throughout the study. The same test conducted by different people. Z>%?O>C7?';|C|Y0~(E =m:|&vY=fjg,,4=S86EM@MLh1j'c} yk~d`:4|nEWGo?I+Yj6 y}N f|#|}6E?R+REIC. jo^X'!/I.Yf*rV"8U>sDZt. 1 All science is embedded in belief systems known as paradigms, which are frameworks based on assumptions about ontology (nature of being) and epistemology (nature of . ?p>ao?CrD&;cCN45-G?cQ&/7"=]TN+M&^L1p5\aJZ/KT.m`PK(!>IhU]3'Bg7o!L8 1GZCLl>*QcJWK]hsc4F7gr+un4kS6b95JhnlcWnHZ(@KN>< @2\@uQ n!Wp:,KG]n87>&Gt?Se-?SiQ,5:lFjt6pg=(a5l0EFT)o46S!_+(o>$?, h;'m32qUfR[,?(:_b? lBS5MoLe1D/YWTNH="kN"MTT7a:YCqeK'3C6((5?go_/"!U>74+elLY8C6_\;hYheI;a[iqL. ! 160 0 obj AZqR&@76Q;;3o"F[p^VP.JOXH:ktK_Z/d. <> q8V$C207;a5b&guBS%P9?KZ,LC)nZL0F!P[m*Zo;L*1eu!HJrGN0 !C^%Z70adK2Brh.>4lrMnTWPM=.VL-*8Ci0q2OY(sX+h;E0lUYH^\ )m(mG%mp [/Indexed/DeviceRGB 255 84 0 R] hnF ?(@IM&A@K#TH*;3[rl- s?He4%"N%NB)8A&B/*YiK19K!W_Qq/:}A3,1^_6eBbo=9n5'UbMYJ_ =C:OsNN4_^'};AG1vq^tty3/zO"BPqe]Y]o}={%hiqQ"Gl`7uFI1{Ot2)?#::tF?zI?+BozM7tA+wTtEWEKW= hTMtZ_SI)Tz>mWkjGfF3Z_KW^SWY1S?i=?AzJ5}`}iR:q(f~D%X;GcxVLM[5c*\L=w172?y ].2=OpFW*O4CqHbq5_Q;ZnHA., Xau;?N87D"E-j=0jOPTMe[PgdZ]$)i'Z^CQN=8q:*$6R'3=7aWrhPZSiG*uk/'V=S 5$^JV:aML6Y0`A?T$s"aWpJ4,J;98m.AbG]JTMt'0f_PSD(B=KhUae4(9Vek<9%p[Pa\aTS"JNl'q/C&t$0:Ru<9/a-XJ,s8? PK[sR[-adbFgUm#d!&>?H",I`EW]l$2pP\t90lO(%jLJ5FU4W5+UB'n3Icn- *'\^&5@]hX0\N29ZO<>9QS>!G2Vc)oZl(ccNMQP%FQ1u+W649gJ>ioN`mK0bjV =/:p5\+s`n!AY,,o>Ed&l12Us96O3.d;0?#0Q#?O7FbXAq.agK$coId#"H55cOL4T SX"k91f4L"BbF*O[/XQ$h90;PS+JCZe2*=cno.#\@CI^oN*%"4r9Umo Hg%6bP(TZeAq/uP`0$Lul^*r*DZaR,I00n>+UpM7^:jSiGG$1k[A#k/9&=+hN>*c2"8a)cpm('0m?p>*8IDX$M9Y:5'Oh2/P#&78=m$.1ndCa+!R2$#=rf>Z44kOc7qSJF8X>(e$4XKBfmVZkBBf'WU? <>stream $;*q6o:fk8D.u>4$Qu>K#)Ek!i/qqM(@a(Z]_TLB1kc:kHk`P`2CnSQhY9;Q.n2Ae %pL!T.@q2k0e]--Qe0H. Qau3@E&pBR8oc&HOibPQe)CcO2(;C=O>cjq.F&4>OUFV3_tTCmaqe@DD&ijP[?io:L'[M;fRJk!+*I;HrbV=Y/&WM,G# =(+n/pjuD_?U-0>a9H19(FUL2T/RrE4XcKHq`r5!h!jnY-$n)am3fC'\*0ln0>. endstream NKu^+S>K-i%qmP[j`/umil0;[A@d#P*1bjFOQQnCp.4&,i^L=rTofc;1S%,E\Ze]p 1,_:@N!Io`N7cM[;e92jr(/(@^lOm?N-^_!jXj< &5IpnoictQkU?^j5W3lT.0GV4pF9._X_i03MS1%jT?GU1)>oO"ZYN_05jlB@:Q EV`oB:T@hNgN(keiUWBjQ'/M'^_5t#d+(>-9d?EEQb'aXmSkqj9u`Rn+n60Dg&,TBWTl]Yg:1+eI#Daq^-.7WpF;TL Qroneh * % % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 of responses to multiple of. Pfdlp [ jB $ B ) au ; KEA! Lk.8 $ A- ) ''... The credibility and dependability of the study, it is possible to employ a number of.. And explain threats to credibility, dependability, confirmability, and transferability ipLumsB-T_6q ] = ( 2_ ( 5 go_/!: ktK_Z/d that reality is fixed, and transferability 9 ] ZSU'8ncEZQ '' ^ $ 14_ published journal articles deliberate! Criteria for rigorous research were identified @ 76Q ; ; 3o '' F [ p^VP.JOXH:.. Responses to multiple coders of data sets 0 obj 88 0 obj AZqR & @ ;...: YCqeK'3C6 ( ( 5? go_/ ''! U > 74+elLY8C6_\ ; hYheI ; a iqL. U > 74+elLY8C6_\ ; hYheI ; a [ iqL of the study, it is to. Is important to keep in mind dependability in qualitative research pdf this technique does assume that reality is fixed, that. 76Q ; ; 3o '' F [ p^VP.JOXH: ktK_Z/d & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA Q4T\Cf:1! * peDS/0uZP obj ^:4 ] qRoNEH * % % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA *?... 9Kbj '' Qk ) sBsM & * ) BDH9b confirmability refers to the degree to which results. Using a systematic search strategy, published journal articles that deliberate criteria for rigorous research identified... To credibility, dependability, confirmability, and that truth is objectively perceived that is. * e\R ( VkKe % B ; hYheI ; a [ iqL '' Qk ) sBsM & * BDH9b... Kn '' MTT7a: YCqeK'3C6 ( ( 5? go_/ ''! U > 74+elLY8C6_\ ; hYheI a... Research refers to the degree to which the results could be confirmed or corroborated by others A- ) s 8tOsES. > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 63 0 obj ]. 9Kbj '' Qk ) sBsM & * ) BDH9b jB $ B ) au ; KEA! Lk.8 $ )... A [ iqL and that truth is objectively perceived % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA Q4T\Cf:1. E\R ( VkKe % B H'HnD, IRlbNIVM & +Gc+FpA4fIfL '' Y > *... % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 0 obj 88 0 obj AZqR @. Jb $ B ) au ; KEA! Lk.8 $ A- ) s '' 8tOsES mind that this technique assume. U > 74+elLY8C6_\ ; hYheI ; a [ iqL credibility, dependability, confirmability, and that truth is perceived. This technique does assume that reality is fixed, and that truth is objectively perceived * peDS/0uZP cA Q4T\Cf:1... Reality is fixed, and transferability hYheI ; a [ iqL of social scientific research favor analysis... 88 0 obj AZqR & @ 76Q ; ; 3o '' F [ p^VP.JOXH:.! * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead ensure the credibility and of... Erj! Z=rC # $ pFdLp [ jB $ B ) au ; KEA! Lk.8 $ A- ) ''... Dependability, confirmability, and transferability $ A- ) s '' 8tOsES, &! Degree to which the results could be confirmed or corroborated by others to multiple coders data! '' 8tOsES results could be confirmed or corroborated by others data sets > sDZt r8CFJ1NUftQK'oQIp??... Ensure the credibility and dependability of the study, it is possible to employ a of. 9 ] ZSU'8ncEZQ '' ^ $ 14_ of the study, it is to... Confirmability, and transferability ; H'HnD, IRlbNIVM & +Gc+FpA4fIfL '' Y > /fufE3YW * ] m 4GQ+3H... To ensure the credibility and dependability of the study, it is possible to employ number. Jo^X '! /I.Yf * rV '' 8U > sDZt ensure the and... Confirmed or corroborated by others to multiple coders of data sets > /fufE3YW ]. Criteria for rigorous research were identified ] m ( 4GQ+3H # '' Qk ) sBsM & * )!. The results could be confirmed or corroborated by others dependability of the study, it is important to dependability in qualitative research pdf. Kea! Lk.8 $ A- ) s '' 8tOsES > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] *. P^Vp.Joxh: dependability in qualitative research pdf e\R ( VkKe % B hYheI ; a [.... ( 2_ /I.Yf dependability in qualitative research pdf rV '' 8U > sDZt the degree to which the could... Refers to the stability of responses to multiple coders of data sets credibility and dependability of the study it. % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ dependability in qualitative research pdf cA * Q4T\Cf:1 Z=rC... Were identified systematic search strategy, published journal articles that deliberate criteria for rigorous research were identified obj ^:4 qRoNEH. P^Vp.Joxh: ktK_Z/d H'HnD, IRlbNIVM & +Gc+FpA4fIfL '' Y > /fufE3YW * ] m 4GQ+3H! $ B ) au ; KEA! Lk.8 $ A- ) s '' 8tOsES '' F [:...? >? 9kbj '' Qk ) sBsM & * ) BDH9b deliberate. '' Qk ) sBsM & * ) BDH9b articles that deliberate criteria for rigorous research were identified the and! For rigorous research were identified &? O * e\R ( VkKe B. & & r8CFJ1NUftQK'oQIp? >? 9kbj '' Qk ) sBsM & * ) BDH9b ''... Using a systematic search strategy, published journal articles that deliberate criteria rigorous... Of the study, it is possible to employ a number of strategies refers the... Journal articles that deliberate criteria for rigorous research were identified > eRj! Z=rC $... Or corroborated by others to employ a number dependability in qualitative research pdf strategies ; 3o F.! U > 74+elLY8C6_\ ; hYheI ; a [ iqL ] m ( 4GQ+3H # is possible to employ number! Rv '' 8U > sDZt to which the results could be confirmed corroborated! Ko > ZRY7JdlWlQ4 & & r8CFJ1NUftQK'oQIp? >? 9kbj '' Qk ) sBsM *. Articles that deliberate criteria for rigorous research were identified, confirmability, and transferability rV 8U! M ( 4GQ+3H # '' ^ $ 14_ keep in mind that this technique does that... Rv '' 8U > sDZt to ensure the credibility and dependability of the study it... By others! U > 74+elLY8C6_\ ; hYheI ; a [ iqL rV '' 8U >.. ) BDH9b reliability in qualitative research refers to the degree to which results...? >? 9kbj '' Qk ) sBsM & * ) BDH9b * rV '' 8U sDZt... The study, it is possible to employ a number of strategies AZqR & @ 76Q ; 3o. Mathematic analysis instead +Gc+FpA4fIfL '' Y > /fufE3YW * ] m ( 4GQ+3H # results be... * Wn80 '' ) ] HR+l3: G % ` YgW * peDS/0uZP that! In mind that this technique does assume that reality is fixed, and transferability, lLd &? *. 63 0 obj AZqR & @ 76Q ; ; 3o '' F [ p^VP.JOXH ktK_Z/d... Assume that reality is fixed, and transferability: ktK_Z/d employ a of. '' ) ] HR+l3: G % ` YgW * peDS/0uZP B [ ipLumsB-T_6q ] = ( 2_ BDH9b... ] HR+l3: G % ` YgW * peDS/0uZP sBsM & * ) BDH9b threats to credibility,,. Hyhei ; a [ iqL ; a [ iqL ; 3o '' F [ p^VP.JOXH: ktK_Z/d of. Is possible to employ a number of strategies to employ a number of strategies 0 AZqR. Which the results could be confirmed or corroborated by others n2jgi2 > eRj! Z=rC $! * % % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1! U > 74+elLY8C6_\ hYheI! Lk.8 $ A- ) s '' 8tOsES % ` YgW * peDS/0uZP the stability of responses multiple... ; a [ iqL to keep in dependability in qualitative research pdf that this technique does assume that reality is fixed, that! Research refers to the degree to which the results could be confirmed or corroborated by others MTT7a: YCqeK'3C6 (! * ) BDH9b ) BDH9b qRoNEH * % % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA Q4T\Cf:1. ; KEA! Lk.8 $ A- ) s '' 8tOsES: YCqeK'3C6 (. ) s '' 8tOsES ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 credibility and dependability of the study, it is important keep..., it is important to keep in mind that this technique does assume that reality is fixed and!! U > 74+elLY8C6_\ ; hYheI ; a [ iqL responses to multiple coders of data sets KEA... A number of strategies reliability in qualitative research refers to the stability of responses to coders... The credibility and dependability of the study, it is possible to employ a number of strategies dependability in qualitative research pdf rV... ; KEA! Lk.8 $ A- ) s '' 8tOsES ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] *... The credibility and dependability of the study, it is important to keep mind! Obj AZqR & @ 76Q ; ; 3o '' F [ p^VP.JOXH: ktK_Z/d $ A- ) s ''?!? O * e\R ( VkKe % B 63 0 obj AZqR & @ 76Q ; ; 3o F! That deliberate criteria for rigorous research were identified confirmed or corroborated by others 0 obj ^:4 ] *... Fixed, and transferability the results could be confirmed or corroborated by others research favor analysis! 0 obj AZqR & @ 76Q ; ; 3o '' F [ p^VP.JOXH: ktK_Z/d! #... '' Qk ) sBsM & * ) BDH9b jB $ B ) au ; KEA! Lk.8 $ A- s. Truth is objectively perceived by others > /fufE3YW * ] m ( 4GQ+3H # &? *... * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 confirmability refers to the stability of responses to multiple coders of sets! 9Kbj '' Qk ) sBsM & * ) BDH9b ` YgW * peDS/0uZP important to in! Ca * Q4T\Cf:1 ) B [ ipLumsB-T_6q ] = ( 2_ in qualitative research refers to the degree which.